~~Xanga and the Seven Dirty Words~~
Xanga has a quirky policy about the acceptability of usernames. First off, not all are acceptable! You just might go to register a username and get one of a few responses:
Your username must be at least three (3) characters long.
Username can only contain characters 0-9, a-z, A-Z, or _
Username is invalid.
The first two are well-defined rules, both instructive and easy to comply with. That is, once you understand the limits of either of these rules, you’d have to be an idiot to try or retry establishing, for instance, a 2-letter username (‘Me’) or one that looked like ‘~~!!!me!!!~~’ . The key is that once you understand the rule, you know beforehand what’s acceptable and what’s not.
But the third response, ‘Username is invalid.’, is not a rule at all. It is merely a report of what appears to be an attempted violation of some rule. But what rule might that be? How can we be sure beforehand what is valid and invalid?
It appears that ‘Username is invalid.’ occurs in at least two instances: 1) usernames with the string ‘xanga’ in it (for example, ‘xangaboy’ or ‘xangagirl are currently invalid—although some others like ‘XangaGina’ and ‘xangaholic’ are ok!), and 2) some so-called ‘dirty words’.
We’ll get back to the ‘xanga’ exceptions in a moment. But first…
On to dirty words. We all know what those are, don’t we? Or do we? (And even if we assume we do, we’ll surely still find a broad difference of opinion amongst us about their acceptability.) So is the Xanga rule: ‘No dirty (i.e., offensive) names allowed.’ ?? Let’s assume it is. Then surely we might expect the infamous ‘Seven Dirty Words’ restricted by the FCC on TV and radio to find disfavor here also:
1) shit
2) piss
3) fuck
4) cunt
5) cocksucker
6) motherfucker
7) tits
Guess again. Of these seven, only ‘cocksucker’ is disallowed on Xanga. The other six are valid usernames (and I have one of them). Funny thing is, though, many (though not all) of the variants on some of these are disallowed! Hence, ‘motherfucker’ is ok, but ‘uglymotherfucker’ is not. ‘fuck’ is ok, but ‘dumbfuck’ is not, and so on. Although it appears that all variants of ‘shit’, ‘piss’, and ‘tits’ are currently allowed.
So, what do we know so far? That Xanga doesn’t ban the ‘Seven Dirty Words’ per se (only one of them), but it does ban some variants, and some that are probably less generally offensive than the root word, i.e., ‘dumbfuck’ generally being considered less offensive than a simple ‘fuck’. It is very hard to discern a rule here! But here is what I speculate:
1) Sometime early in 2001, Xanga ‘grandfathered in a few ‘dirty word’ accounts that existed prior to making certain usernames (and variants) invalid (e.g., ‘fuck’, est. 12/28/2000), but banned all subsequent unclaimed names and variants of such thereafter until...
2) October 2003. During the month of October 2003, it appears that many then currently banned names became allowable! Yes, October 2003 was The Great Diaspora of Foulness in Xanga. Heh Lots of ‘fuck’ names (e.g., ‘motherfucker’) , ‘bitch’ names (‘bitch’ itself), even ‘xanga’ names (‘XangaGina’ and ‘xangaholic’ mentioned above) were claimed. But if you personally didn’t get yours then, forget it. It appears that the door has since again been slammed.
So today we have certain restrictions on naming with lots and lots of exceptions. The question is: Why was October 2003 so special? Why were so many exceptions then allowed that had been prior and have since been banned?
Enough speculation for me (though I encourage you to do so in comments). Here’s two lists. Which, if either, do you find more offensive?
Some non-existent and currently disallowed Xanga Usernames ("Username is invalid.")
orgasm
orgasmic
penis
xangamom
blogbitch
bastard
pussy
shitfuck
cumfuck
bitchwhip
littlecunt
tightpussy
pussycats
cocksucker
uglymotherfucker
dumbfuck
Some perfectly good existing Xanga Usernames
piss
shit
fuck
cunt
cunt_rag
cum_guzzler
coitus
bitch
fuck_off_bitch
shitandshutup
cummonster
pussycat
tits
cock
motherfucker
goddamn
What’s that story about Pandora’s Box?!
Okay. So how’s this for a rule:
‘pussy’ is offensive—nonexistent and disallowed,
‘pussycat’ is apparently fine and allowed (October 18 2003),
‘pussycats’ is now offensive—and disallowed!
Dirty, dirty pussycats!
Recent Comments